Don Lemon’s arrest involved a gay journalist & conservative church. That’s no coincidence.

Don Lemon is getting charged under a bill meant to restrain the Klan in perhaps the year’s best example (so far) of “Every Republican accusation is a confession.”
Lemon’s arrest is another line that the current administration has crossed on the road to totalitarianism, one that people should be paying attention to. The administration hates journalists and has been attacking them in civil court, excluding them from briefings due to their coverage, insulting them to their faces, and threatening their employers’ business deals to get them fired. But now it’s using the criminal justice system to attack a journalist, literally for committing acts of journalism.
Related
The media is mocking Trump’s dishonest attempts to destroy the free press
And they chose to cross this line in a situation that involves a conservative Christian church and a gay journalist. This is not an accident.
Lemon went to the scene of a protest last month at St. Paul, Minnesota’s Cities Church, a mostly-white, conservative Christian church where one of the pastors works for ICE. The protest was organized by local Black Lives Matter groups. Like many protests that have taken place in churches, this one was co-organized by at least one Christian preacher guided by her faith.
Dive deeper every day
Join our newsletter for thought-provoking commentary that goes beyond the surface of LGBTQ+ issues
Subscribe to our Newsletter today
Lemon covered the protest as a journalist. Even the criminal indictment agrees. He is facing one count of “Conspiracy Against Right of Religious Freedom at Place of Worship,” that he intimidated people who were trying to attend a church service, and here is exactly what the indictment says Lemon did to “injure, oppress, threaten, and intimidate” people in the church (these are all quotes from the indictment):
- LEMON began livestreaming his internet-based show, “The Don Lemon Show,” where he explained to his audience that he was in Minnesota with an organization that was gearing up for a “resistance” operation against the Federal Government’s immigration policies
- LEMON observed that the congregants’ reactions were understandable because the experience was “traumatic and uncomfortable,” which he said was the purpose
- LEMON [and other defendants] approached the pastor and largely surrounded him, stood in close proximity to the pastor in an attempt to oppress and intimidate him, and physically obstructed his freedom of movement while LEMON peppered him with questions to promote the operation’s message
- LEMON stood so close to the pastor that LEMON caused the pastor’s right hand to graze LEMON, who then admonished the pastor, “Please don’t push me.”
- [After being told to leave] LEMON and the other defendants ignored the pastor’s request and did not immediately leave the Church
- LEMON posted himself at the main door of the Church, where he confronted some congregants and physically obstructed them as they tried to exit the Church building to challenge them with “facts” about U.S. immigration policy
That’s it. He asked people questions and livestreamed the protest. He made observations about what was going on. He interviewed congregants and let them express themselves on air. All of this is on YouTube. Congregants don’t seem intimidated by him as they’re standing next to him, being interviewed.
He didn’t threaten anyone with violence. He didn’t hit anyone. The only physical contact he had with any member of the church was when the pastor touched him.
Lemon is facing charges for broadcasting an event, asking people questions, and making observations based on what he saw. Those are all acts of journalism. Even if Lemon himself is liberal.
(Yes, there is the question of whether he was trespassing, which is actually not that obvious since the church was a space that is open to people coming in, even non-members, and he wasn’t told he was trespassing. But trespassing is a local issue, and he is facing federal charges based on the supposed intimidation.)
And the administration is making this specifically about religion, portraying it as an attack on Christians.
“Nobody is above the law. Especially not today’s klansmen — like Don Lemon — who storm churches and terrorize Christians,” said a post shared by Assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights Harmeet Dhillon. He is facing charges under a Reconstruction Era law that was intended to protect Black people’s rights to, among other things, attend church without interference from the Klan.
Attorney General Pam Bondi accused Lemon of “performing an attack-style infiltration of a church,” as if church-goers were in physical danger, as if the goal of the protest was to hurt Christians for being Christians and not protest ICE for terrorizing the city and arresting people of color in the street.
This is despite the fact that it was co-organized by Nekima Levy Armstrong, a civil rights lawyer who also preaches at Minneapolis’s First Covenant Church. Her message was religious, one Christian expressing her faith to other Christians by asking at the protest: “How dare you claim to be a pastor of God and you are involved in evil in our community?”
Lemon himself, like many LGBTQ+ people, was raised in the church and still considers his faith important to him, so important that he even wrote a whole book about his “search for God.”
Even though this was a protest among Christians, the administration is portraying it as anti-Christian because one side is conservative white Christians, the only kind of Christians that Republicans recognize as legitimate. To conservative Christians, progressive Christians are suspect, and LGBTQ+ people, no matter their faith, are the enemy of religiosity itself.
Lemon will likely be fine here. He is established enough and connected enough – and the judge seems skeptical enough – that he will likely get the charges dismissed.
But this was intended to be an act of intimidation to other journalists, and some people in this profession, especially those without the resources Lemon has, will likely ask themselves if a story is worth going to
It has also become really clear in the past year that the president doesn’t see himself as the president of the whole country. It’s not like past presidents, even Republicans, who acted like they were elected to a real political office whose constituents included people who didn’t vote for them.
For this president, it’s like he thinks he’s the leader of a group of thugs, and he somehow got his hands on the levers of power. He has no sense of justice or responsibility, not even the warped, biased sense of justice and responsibility that, say, George W. Bush had.
For the current president, power is to be used to benefit himself personally and then the people he perceives as a part of his coalition. And Lemon, as an educated Black gay journalist, is clearly not a part of that coalition.
Subscribe to the LGBTQ Nation newsletter and be the first to know about the latest headlines shaping LGBTQ+ communities worldwide.